Based in London and writing for a global audience our aim is to produce EliteFootballTalk. Enjoy the site and feel welcome to join in our discussion on the beautiful game.

Wednesday, November 16, 2005

Who would you select in best ever Gunners' XI?

GunnerPete emailed me with this question and the suggestion that it should be put to Arsenal supporters everywhere.

GunnerPete has been supporting AFC since 1948, so his own selection of Gunners' greats is based on a depth of knowledge that is both immense and impressive. His 4-4-2 selection (and reasoning behind each pick) is:

Howe_McLintock_Adams__ Hapgood

Jack Kelsey....he was without doubt the greatest commander of a penalty area I have ever seen, and you have to remember that during his time we had some of the worst defenders in our history. I genuinely believe that Jack kept us in the first division almost single handed a couple of seasons. I was lucky to meet him many times after he retired, because I was working at Finsbury Park & he was running some early fund raising scheme. He was so modest and genuine, its hard to believe in the context of today's players. My second & third choice Goalie are.....Seaman & Jennings.

Don Howe.........I remember how wingers used to disappear when playing against us, and when so called wonder men from Brazil were up against him. He was a really great thinking defender. He was a stopper, like Sol, but Don could pass. Tactically, he was the best ever, as he organised all those around him, like he did after he retired. 2nd / 3rd......Rice & Dixon.

Tony Adams......Don't think I need to say much about big Tone. You want to have the will to win in all weathers and against all types of opposition, and with the worst biased officials, you pick him. AND he was a great defender too!
2nd / 3rd = Bould & Simpson.

Frank Mclintock...I remember Frank's first game after AFC paying out a record fee for a midfielder. We were murdered at home and he was terrible. His face said it all " what have I joined here"? It took at least 6 months before he decided what role we needed, and he began to take over defensive duties alongside starting most of our attacks. He became the best timer of a tackle I had seen, and never gave up whatever the score, home or away. A thing some of our foreign players will never learn. I shall never forget his greatest game, when he drove our young pre double winning side of 1971, to overcome a better side (Anderlecht) to win 3-0 in the Final, after being 3-1 down from the first leg.......stupendous ! 2nd / 3rd....Roberts & Campbell.

Eddie Hapgood...Like Tony Adams, Eddie was a great organiser (according to my Dad, who was a Chelsea Supporter) His positional sense was uncanny, very similar to Bobby Moore, no pace but they did not pass him often. He was also the most dapper in his appearance on and off the field. He would be my Captain too. 2nd = Samson.

David Rocastle...What potential he had that was not completely realised. I believe he was sold because George Graham had been told of a knee injury that would return for longer & longer periods as his career progressed. AFC, wrongly decided to cash in on him, and helped destroy his wonderful AFC & England future. He had the lot. Pace, strength, shot, & defensive ability second to none. I remember meeting Geordie Armstrong in my village in Cambridge, a couple of times, and he raved about David. Geordie knew what he was talking about, being one of the best ever. 2nd / 3rd.....Mcleod & Clapton.

Alex James.....Well, what can you say about a player who can knock Liam Brady out of any team. Apart from my Dad, all my family ancestors, were Gunners, and before the great George Eastham & Jimmy Logie, we had Alex. He was often a few drinks for the worse, but my family say that his skill was of the level of Maradona, and that says it all except that the podgy Argy never played with the huge leather ball, with very painful laces right across the top. He also never played in the mud that Alex played on week in, week out, and he was tiny. One cup match I heard about was a sensation: when the opposing Manager told his defenders to not bother with James just cut out his final pass, because he does not score. Alex then scored the first hat-trick of his career. When people talk about George Best, it makes me squirm, because although a great player, he never faced the defenders Alex did or the pitches etc. AND most of all, he was at a club that media have always overdone the praise since the tragic 1957 crash. That was when we all supported Man, U. for a year. " 2nd / 3rd = Brady & Eastham.

Patrick Vieira......All I will say is that he is unique. I cannot remember any past player to compare Pat with. The nearest I came was Tommy Docherty (who was great & never mentioned now as a player). Alex Forbes, was very hard, but lacked finesse.
Pat should have seen his career out at AFC. The stadium deserved him, and I hate to say it but, watch out when the 'love in' at Juventus wanes (T adds that Overmars, Petit, etc found that the grass was not greener away from Highbury, but hopes Pat has a better time at Juve). 2nd / 3rd Docherty & Bowen

Cliff Bastin.......The simple fact that it took a super striker like Wright to beat Cliffs record, says it all. He was so rare. A goal-scoring winger who made so many for others and frightened the opposition to death; he was very similar to Henry today. He actually (from the wing) scored his total in many less matches that Ian or Thierry, but with so much modesty. One day when the so called experts who run the polls in the media, actually take a look at all teams for the greatest ever players in the UK, and not just from favourites like Man, U. Liverpool & Spurs, you will see Cliff up there with Best, Pele, James & Maradona.
2nd / 3rd = Pires & Haverty.

Ted Drake.......I think I am right in saying that Ted still holds the record for a one man score in top football. He scored seven against Villa, and the best story came from the Ref after the game when interviewed, he said " When I disallowed what would have been 'Teds' eighth goal, he asked why, and all I could say was, don't be greedy Ted, seven is enough for anyone" . After the game the ref admitted he had got that decision wrong! The biggest joke about this match was that Ted should not have played due to injury, but started with his leg heavily strapped. He also hit the bar. Ted was fearless, but controlled. His footwork was excellent and he was a great team man. BUT, he was without doubt the best header of a ball AFC ever had. The only other player I saw as good was Jackie Milburn (Newcastle). He only edges Wrighty out because of Teds variation. 2nd / 3rd David Jack & Bergkamp

Thierry Henry......Absolutely no doubt who should be my number 10. Thierry, is the greatest striking forward Ive ever seen, and that includes Galacticos such as.......Drake, Wright, Dalglesh, Lawton, Pele, Maradona, Eusebio, Puskas, Van Basten, Best, Greaves, Law, and many, many more . The difference, which is enormous, is that TH, creates more than any other player that Ive seen. BUT his conversion record is second to none. Only Greaves made scoring look as simple, but Jim could not score from 25/35 yards. If TH, ever learned how to head a ball, he would score 40/50 per year, and against the organised defences we have world wide now days, that is sensational. My mind boggles when I remember the pace of yesteryear, and how there was no falling back to help your defence etc. Very little packed defences, and you played with injuries week in week out. Today, stars miss 6/10 games per year that in the 1950 / 60's, they would have had to play.
2nd /3rd Wright & Joe Baker

GunnerPete's subs: "pick 6 out of this lot":-
Seaman, Jennings, George, Mcleod, Bowen, Docherty, McNab, Cole, Male, Pires, Bould, Roberts, Howe, Compton, Rice, Simpson, Radford, Logie, Baker, Clapton, Toure, Tapscott, O'leary, Bergkamp, Winterburn, Brady, Petit, Reg Lewis, David Jack, Forbes, Lishman, Holton, Barnes, Samson, Lambert.

My own selection is based on being an AFC supporter since 1988, so I must rely only on what I have heard and read about the past Arsenal greats' that are pre-Graham and Wenger.

My 4-4-2 selection is:

Dixon__ McLintock_Adams_Hapgood

Kelsey: Informed Arsenal watchers say he has not been surpassed by Jennings, Wilson or Seaman. Also goalie for Wales team that reached quarters of World Cup 1958 before losing 1-0 to Brazil.

Dixon: For 15 years gave 100% commitment under Graham and Wenger, picking up 4 championship medals along the way.

Hapgood: England captain left-back who played 434 over 11 seasons during prolonged era of Arsenal domination in 1930's.

Adams: Colossus of a leader that marshalled the world's famous Arsenal water-tight defence for 16 years. Led AFC to four championship wins (including two doubles) under Graham & Wenger, three FA Cups, and the European Cup Winners Cup (when English teams were generally struggling in Europe).

McLintock: 1970-71 double-winning captain.

Overmars: Only with Arsenal for three seasons (integral to winning the double in his first), an awesome winger with supreme ball-control sprinting speed; determination; and killer instinct in front of goal. I had to find a place for him in my starting line-up so placed him on the right because Bastin is unremovable from the left wing position.

Vieira: A one-off CM phenomenon: great ball-control, stamina, tackling ability, accurate & quick passer, unlimited passion, ultimate team-player, and captain of the Arsenal 49ers.

James: Key-man, playmaker, and prolific assist-provider of 1930's team that dominated and revolutionised football.

Bastin: 176 goals from left wing, his lethal form of wing play (along with Hulme on the right) was ground-breaking.

Drake: An outstanding strike-rate of 136 goals in 182 games before the war ended his AFC playing career sees him edge out Legend Dennis (whose 'rolling back the years' performance against Man Utd in the 4-2 defeat last February will always live long in my memory).

Henry: To quote Andy Gray (fantastic piece of commentary after TH scored his fourth against Leeds in the unbeaten season): "I’ve seen most things in top flight English Football over the last 25years or so – but I’ve never seen anything like him!". The ultimate striker with limitless potential (which was immediately evident when closely watching him for the first time in an AFC shirt), a goals and assists record that is simple incredible, a consistency which is unsurpassed, a combination of awesome technique, pace, skill, passion, and finishing ability that is untouchable and thrilling to watch, and a sportsman in every sense of the word. Star player in his six and a bit seasons at the club; won the Premiership twice, FA Cup three times, but no Champs League success for AFC…. yet!

I definitely recommend thinking about and selecting your own greatest Gunners' team. Recalling those AFC greats' that you have seen play, or read and heard others' speak about, simply reinforces the belief that Arsenal is a uniquely great football club with a long and rich competitive football history at the top of the English game…. and with many more years of it still to come!

I'll open up EFT for you to compile your own greatest Gunners' team, and to discuss the merit's of all our selections. Many thanx again GunnerPete for your suggestion and input…


Blogger lowesmore said...

My all time team, based on 32 years of support would have to be

The subs bench would be
Jennings, Winterburn, Rocastle, Overmars and O'Leary.
I'm not entirely happy with the 4-3-1-2 formation, but can't get past the idea of that fabulous three pronged attack!

11/16/2005 12:09 pm

Anonymous Anonymous said...

My all time arsenal 11 since being an arsenal supporter all my life.


11/16/2005 12:38 pm

Anonymous Anonymous said...

My all time gooners 11...I've been a fan sicne I was 6 (1989!).


Subs: Jennings/Bould/Bastin/Pires/

11/16/2005 1:00 pm

Anonymous Anonymous said...

These would kick butt.
Flatts Ceaser Linighan Grondin
Groves Hillier Morrow Mcgoldrick
K Campbell Rizza

Oh yes.

11/16/2005 1:06 pm

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Rice McClintock Adams Cole
Storey Viera
Pires Henry
Wright George

37 years supporting.
Derry Gooner

11/16/2005 1:30 pm

Anonymous Anonymous said...

My all-time Arsenal team looks like this (a Gunner since 1990!):

Dixon McLintock Adams Sansom
Rocastle Vieira Brady Overmars
---------Wright Henry

Subs: Bergkamp, Bastin, Pires, Campbell, James, Kelsey.

11/16/2005 1:36 pm

Anonymous Anonymous said...

My team is based on the players i have seen play in my lifetime, live or on TV. Most of u may not agree, but i believe u gotta give credit where credit is due for being the first team to set the 49 unbeaten record (especially seeing as Chavski spent 500 million to try to beat it and failed, Ha, ha)

1st choice
Goal = mad jens (48ers)
LB = cole (49ers)
RB = Lauren (48ers)
CB = Adams (Legend)
CB = Bould(Real Class,v composed)
LW = Pires(best i seen for us,plenty assists and goals + 49ers )
RW = Freddie (v.underatted -Loads of goals (debut goal against mancs +49ers)
CM = Viera (best ive seen + 49ers)
CM = Rocastle/Thomas (i think rocky was a better player but always have a place for thomas ca of the winning goal at anfield that got us the league)
FW = Berkamp (technically the best player i have ever seen also most creative, a legend + 49ers)
FW = Henry (Da King + 49ers)

my second 11

GK = Seamen
LB = winterburn
BB = dixon
CB = Cambell
CB = Keown
LW = Overmars
RW = Merson/parlour
CM = DAvis
CM = Edu
FW = Wright
FW = Anelka

Two good teams if you ask me

11/16/2005 2:13 pm

Anonymous Anonymous said...

How about


sub Henry

11/16/2005 3:02 pm

Blogger T said...

Thanx for the feedback so far everyone. The great thing about this question is that while there is no definitive right answer, all the team's selected will still have great merit... even the 'lesser talents' team fielding some of Graham's hard-working players would do a fine job... most of them do have European and domestic cup medals!!!

Although we were looking for 4-4-2, I agree that the 4-3-1-2 selection of Lowesmore is pretty irreisitable! Also agree wih seventh anon that the players who only featured under Graham and Wenger deserve excellent recognition and can form a squad of 22 that I wouldn't mind seeing play evey week for the rest of my AFC supporting life!

Thanx seventh anon for also selecting gutsy Freddie, he really is underrated... and no AFC fan should forget his crucial-goal-after-crucial-goal scoring effort in the closing months of the double winning 2001-2002 season, with excellent red streak Gunners' haircut to boot!

11/16/2005 4:43 pm

Anonymous IL-Gooner said...

If it were possible, i'd field the following team:





And I'm not even sure Henry couldn't have been a good goalie too! :)

Seriously now, I can't say anything about players I haven't seen (I'm a Gunner since 1988). I have two comments though:

1. I feel that Pires at his best was a more complete player than Overmars. I really loved Overmars, he had great pace, technique and finishing; but Pires can (or at least could) make his teamates look better. He was astonishing in the 2001/2 season until his injury - when Freddie made a superb effort in replacing Pires on the left side.

2. Anders Limpar. How could you all forget him? I really loved Rocky, but injuries meant he never became the player he could be. Limpar was at his peak in Arsenal - and he was awesome in the 1990/1 championship. He could score from nearly impossible situations... Ah, memories... Luckily Arsenal is giving us so many new great memories, we can sometimes forget players like Limpar...

11/16/2005 5:34 pm

Blogger T said...

Nice comments Il-Gooner. One things for sure, to sell Overmars and have him replaced by Pires is yet more proof that Arsene has an eye for great players- and what's more his training and coaching methods maximises their latent potential!

Thanks for also mentioning Anders Limpar- in his first season we won the championship with only one defeat! Limpar and Magic Man Merson were the two creative sparks in an AFC team of otherwise brilliantly hard-working players... yep, great memories...

11/17/2005 12:07 pm

Anonymous Anonymous said...

GunnerPete..says..Thank you 'T' and all the fans who gave their opinions re; Arsenals greatest ever team. I loved the mixture of real and funny teams, especially the 'all Henry's'. The team with all the 'H's was clever and took some research, but my favourite was the nightmare team of stiffs with Ceaser in it. 'T' and I only disagree on right wingers,I still prefer Rocky to Overmars because of his passion.

I felt bad about leaving out Steve Bould as I really believe England missed out on a great defender. I can also see Arsene making the same mistake, by overlooking the lower divs when searching for new talent.

I think it is also an interesting point that most fans left out 'Cole', when all the media tells us he is rated the best in the world at present. I think his sneaking behind our backs to Chelsea & Real Madrid has shown what he thinks of us fans, so its not surprising he is being ignored by many. When I think of the greats, I also remember loyalty to us the fans. From Hapgood to Rice to McNab, to Sansom, they were with us until their age determined the end, and not money.

I would also like to encourage more older fans to write to 'T' with memories similar to mine, with especial attention to players who have been forgotten ie; Johnny Mcleod, Joe Haverty, Alan Skirton, Jimmy Logie, Dave Bowen, Jimmy Bloomfield, George Eastham, Jon Sammels. These were great in their day, but played in poor teams so the media did not even start to praise them, unless they left and went elsewhere....!

11/23/2005 6:08 pm

Blogger job opportunitya said...

Exciting blog. The site out did itself and will be
back! I love surfing the internet for blogs that are
exactly like this blog.
Look who checking out my compare life insurance blog?

12/02/2005 1:53 am


Post a Comment

<< Home


Locations of visitors to this page